The Boss wrote:I'd be a fan of simple, symbolic pieces that represent the themes of the next album.
As in, revisit that confidence Jones had with "UNDERTOW".
"10,000 DAYS" was just trying waaay too hard.
"LATERALUS" got it with the thematic design. It found a great balance between the intricacy of Grey's work with the band's/Jones' theme. Though it should be shockingly clear at this point that every single thing about that album is perfect to me.
(Yes, even the typo

)
a legitimate response about Tool??? on a Tool forum??!! WOW haha...
I agree with what you said though, Lateralus is a COMPLETE album. Everything flows together; it's an album that you honestly can listen front to back and actually feel a vibe and similar undertones throughout. 10,000 Days was enjoyable for me, I agree it wasnt up to par with Lateralus, but I didnt feel as though it was a let down in any way. However I do hope they return to their Lateralus "roots" on the new album. And I believe they will MUSICALLY, although I am worried that Maynards lyrics may not live up to the Lateralus level. Maynard has written amazing lyrics but they all had an emotion behind them, and I'm just not convinced that he will have the emotions needed to really create great lyrics. He can still draw from his mothers sickness and the pain he felt from that to create music, but he's really done that a lot, and in the words of Maynard, "if the songs dont help me out of something, how are they supposed to help you?".... So if he is still singing about that then it looks as if they havent helped him.
I just worry his only emotions to draw from at this point in his life are mundane and too simple to really get great songs from.... is he going to sing about his grapes not making it through winter? His house not selling as fast as he wants?