F O U R T H E Y E

In the interest of reinvigorating this great concept, I propose we go back to the list-based idea. Furthermore, because we have a lot of members, we'll be doing TWO albums of the week.

Hopefully this way we can make it a bit of a competition, and foster a little more feedback than we usually do. Perhaps at the end of the list we could even vote on who chose the best album?

Please leave a post in this thread if you'd like to be a part of this. Also, if you absolutely must have a certain position on the list, let me know. I'll be assigning everyone a number, then randomising them to come up with a list.

There's no huge rush, so let's call this on the weekend, to be ready to launch early next week. All feedback is welcome.

NOTE: This has nothing to do with the Classic AOTW. As far as I'm concerned, that's a fairly lame idea, and I have nothing to do with it.

The Boss wrote:Furthermore, because we have a lot of members, we'll be doing TWO albums of the week.

I feel this is a bad idea, one album wasn't generating much interest, I don't how adding another one would improve the situation.

I'm happy to give it a go and take part.

Not Tyson wrote:

The Boss wrote:Furthermore, because we have a lot of members, we'll be doing TWO albums of the week.

I feel this is a bad idea, one album wasn't generating much interest, I don't how adding another one would improve the situation.

My theory was because people were getting bored of waiting for their turn. Seriously, we had some people waiting twenty weeks for their turn. How motivated would you be to listen to and comment on other people's picks if you knew no one was going to listen to yours for over three months?

This way, we can cut the waiting time by half, as well as inject some friend banter into the idea. I think maybe even a poll at the end of the list and a prize for the best pick might be a good idea.

If anyone wants to go back to the one album a week for twenty weeks idea, that's fine too.

That wasn't really a problem anymore though. Before Mog posted two yesterday there hadn't been one posted in weeks.

But I'm down for this new idea, anything that keeps this going is fine by me .

The Boss wrote:My theory was because people were getting bored of waiting for their turn. Seriously, we had some people waiting twenty weeks for their turn. How motivated would you be to listen to and comment on other people's picks if you knew no one was going to listen to yours for over three months?

I was actually in it to hear other peoples picks not get mine in front of everyone. I thought that was the point. Yeah it's great to get your turn and all but hearing new music kept me plenty motivated to listen and rate almost all of the AOTWs. No one else even came close to listening to and commenting on all of them. The more recent ones I have slacked off a bit on but I'll get there.

I think you'll be hard pressed to get people to listen to two albums in a week when one couldn't even be handled.

That being said, I like the head to head format and grand champion ideas you have suggested. I was kinda hoping that something like that, grand champion thing, would have happened with the original AOTW, which is why I made this thread that no one participated in... Round 1 recap

Anyway, I'm game to give it a go and see what happens.

Awesome comments, BJ.

You and Tyson may be right, but I have a feeling that the slightly competitive aspect might make this work. I won't be surprised if it doesn't though.

I think by making it more likely for everyone to be heard in a shorter amount of time, we'll all be more likely to be a bit more proactive about commenting and reviewing this time 'round. The competitive aspect will also encourage people to comment and point out why they like one over the other:

I liked Mog's pick better because ISIS own, and I haven't even heard the band Tyson picked, and it sucked anyway because it was hip hop and I hate hip hop.

Don't taze me bro.

As it stands, we already have five weeks of one album or two weeks of two. I'd like to see fifteen to twenty participants.

I'm down. Let me know when I'm up.

Hey... that's kinda confusing...

Three weeks of two.

I might actually call this once we hit twenty. Ten weeks of two should be enough for any forum.

BJ's idea is criminally underrated. Toward the end of each week, I'll make a simple poll where members can vote for their preferred album for that week.

I'll throw it all together after the tenth week, and we should have a winner. Whether or not they win anything is up to Hellboy.

I leave it up to Mog to donate the prize, him being the worlds wealthiest and most qualified man.

I'm OK with that.

BUMP for great justice.

I say just run with it, no need to wait for others to chime in

hellboy wrote:I leave it up to Mog to donate the prize, him being the worlds wealthiest and most qualified man.

Go fuck yourself. Seriously. Who paid for the last comp? Get fucked

Someone needs some anger management classes.

M0G wrote:

hellboy wrote:I leave it up to Mog to donate the prize, him being the worlds wealthiest and most qualified man.

Go fuck yourself. Seriously. Who paid for the last comp? Get fucked

Thanks for reinforcing my point...

hellboy wrote:

M0G wrote:

hellboy wrote:I leave it up to Mog to donate the prize, him being the worlds wealthiest and most qualified man.

Go fuck yourself. Seriously. Who paid for the last comp? Get fucked

Thanks for reinforcing my point...

Anytime. You will never get another cent from me. You are at Tyson level now.

I've already got my two picked, south of the border themed.

Brujeria?

I knew someone would straight of the bat suggest that, nah, this is coming from left field.

In. Anything to promote good music. Well done Mr. Crow

Nice.

Calling it before football on Saturday (4:00pm Sydney time).

Not Tyson wrote:I've already got my two picked, south of the border themed.

I think we need some clarification on the new AOTW process... Tyson seems to think that on his turn, he'll submit TWO at the same time. Correct me if I'm wrong *mate*

But Crow seems to be suggesting that 2 of us will go head to head with ONE pick each per week.

Which is it?

I'll take my answer off the air, thanks.

Oh, that makes more sense.

I thought that was obvious. Why would people be submitting TWO albums? Where's the competition in that?

For example: When it is our turn, Tyson will pick a NICKELBACK album, and I will pick a SOUNDGARDEN album. Everyone will listen to both, then comment on how Tyson's pick sucked donkey balls, and mine rocked. A poll will be conducted at the end of the week, I will win, and my pick will be judged along with others at the end of the season to see who had the best album. Tyson will cry in foetal position for a solid two weeks, and the world will experience peace and happiness for a short time.

Any other questions?